Quick Answer: Interchange-plus saves most Canadian businesses money starting around $3,000/month in processing volume. The savings grow fast — at $25K/month, you're leaving $2,000–$3,000/year on the table with flat-rate pricing. The biggest reason? Interac debit. Flat-rate processors charge you 2.6% on a transaction that costs $0.07.

How Flat-Rate Pricing Works

Square’s published Canadian in-person prices distinguish credit cards (2.5%) from Interac debit (0.75% + $0.07). Canadian accounts use CAD; do not assume a USD conversion is required on domestic sales. See Square Canada pricing.

The appeal is obvious: simple, predictable, easy to understand. You know exactly what each sale costs. No surprises on your statement.

But that simplicity has a price. On a basic Canadian Visa debit card, the actual interchange fee is about 0.60%.

Square’s published Canadian rates are 2.5% for in-person credit, 2.8% + $0.30 for standard online payments, and 0.75% + $0.07 for in-person Interac debit. Calculate costs using the relevant channel and ticket size; these are not interchangeable rates. Source: Square Canada.

How Interchange-Plus Pricing Works

Interchange-plus (or "cost-plus") passes through the actual interchange fee charged by the card network, then adds a fixed markup on top. With Helcim, the base markup is 0.40% + $0.08 for in-person credit transactions.

For an illustrative in-person credit transaction with assumed underlying card costs of 0.60%, Helcim’s base markup adds 0.40% + $0.08: a $50 sale would cost $0.58. The 0.60% input is an assumption, not a universal card rate. Square’s 2.5% in-person credit rate would cost $1.25 on that sale.

Interac has separate pricing: Helcim’s base chip-and-PIN fee is $0.09 and standard contactless is $0.125. Square’s in-person Interac charge is 0.75% + $0.07, or $0.445 on $50. Do not apply credit markup arithmetic to Interac.

The Real Numbers at Every Volume

Here's what a typical Canadian retail business actually pays. Assumptions: 65% in-person / 35% online, 30% of in-person is Interac debit, average transaction $55.

Illustrative in-person domestic credit-card example: $50 average ticket, 1.6% assumed underlying card costs for Helcim before its current markup. All sales are credit; debit, software, hardware, tax, FX, and international charges are excluded. Underlying costs are an assumption, not a verified universal rate.

Monthly credit volumeHelcim estimateStripeSquare
$3,000$64.80$84.00$75.00
$5,000$108.00$140.00$125.00
$10,000$216.00$280.00$250.00
$25,000$540.00$700.00$625.00
$50,000$1,080.00$1,400.00$1,250.00
$100,000$2,090.00$2,800.00$2,500.00

Model updated November 8, 2026. Vary the assumptions in the fee calculator. Sources: Helcim, Stripe, Square.

At $10K/month, switching from flat-rate to interchange-plus saves $85–$125 monthly. That's $1,000–$1,500 a year for doing nothing except changing processors. At $50K/month, you're saving $470–$670 monthly — enough to hire a part-time employee.

Run your own numbers through our fee calculator →

Why Interac Debit Is the Hidden Driver

This is the part most US-focused guides miss entirely, and it's the single biggest reason interchange-plus wins for Canadian businesses.

Interac debit transactions cost processors about $0.05–$0.15 each. Not a percentage — a flat nickel to fifteen cents regardless of transaction size.

On a $200 purchase, Interac costs $0.10. Credit cards cost $3–$5.

That's not a pricing model — it's a subsidy. You're subsidizing the cost of someone else's Aeroplan Visa Infinite.

With interchange-plus pricing, you pay the actual Interac cost ($0.05–$0.15) plus a small markup. On a $100 Interac transaction:

If 30% of your transactions are Interac debit (normal for Canadian retail), interchange-plus saves you a small fortune. Read more about how Interac fees work.

When Flat-Rate Actually Makes Sense

Flat-rate isn't always the worse deal. There are real scenarios where it wins:

Very Low Volume (Under $3,000/month)

The dollar difference is small — maybe $15–$25/month. At that level, simplicity and features matter more than a 0.5% rate difference. Square's free POS, free magstripe reader, and phone support have real value.

High-Interchange Card Mix

Mostly Online, Mostly Credit

Online transactions have higher interchange rates, and you get zero Interac debit benefit online (customers can't tap debit on a website). If you're 100% e-commerce with no debit volume, the savings gap narrows.

Micro-Transactions

The Crossover Point

For a typical Canadian business (mix of debit and credit, $40–$80 average ticket, some in-person and some online), the crossover happens around $2,500–$4,000/month in processing volume.

Below that: flat-rate is fine. The savings from interchange-plus are $10–$20/month — not worth the mental energy of reading interchange statements.

Above that: interchange-plus wins, and the gap widens with every dollar of volume. By $10K/month, you're throwing away $100/month on flat-rate. By $50K, it's $500+.

The "I Don't Want to Read Statements" Objection

Fair concern. Interchange-plus statements are more complex than flat-rate.

You'll see line items for different card types, network fees, and assessments. It looks intimidating.

But here's the thing: you don't need to read them. The total is the total.

And honestly, if you're processing enough volume for the savings to matter ($5K+/month), you should be looking at your processing costs anyway. Ignoring a $100/month expense because the statement has more line items is not a great business decision.

What About Moneris Interchange-Plus?

Moneris also offers interchange-plus pricing, but there's a catch: monthly fees. Moneris charges $24.95–$49.95/month for the account, plus potential terminal rental ($25–$35/month), plus PCI compliance fees ($9.95/month on some plans).

Before you process a single transaction, you could be paying $60–$85/month in fixed costs. Helcim charges $0/month for everything — no monthly fee, no terminal rental, no PCI fee. You'd need to process $15K–$20K/month before Moneris's slightly lower interchange markups offset those fixed costs.

If you're processing $50K+ and have negotiating leverage, Moneris can get competitive. Below that, Helcim's zero-fee structure almost always wins.

Switching Is Easier Than You Think

The biggest barrier to switching from flat-rate to interchange-plus is inertia. People assume it's complicated. It's not.

  1. Sign up with Helcim (takes ~10 minutes, no contract)
  2. Get your card reader shipped (free for qualifying businesses)
  3. Update your online checkout (Helcim has plugins for Shopify, WooCommerce, etc.)
  4. Start processing

No early termination fees with Square or Stripe — you can keep both accounts active during the transition. Process a month on Helcim, compare the actual costs, then decide. See our step-by-step setup guide.

The 2024 Interchange Reduction: The federal government negotiated lower interchange rates with Visa and Mastercard for small businesses, effective in 2024-2025. These reductions benefit interchange-plus merchants directly (lower interchange = lower total cost). Flat-rate merchants? Square and Stripe kept the savings. Your 2.65% rate didn't drop.

🏆 Bottom Line

Flat-rate pricing is a convenience tax. It's fine at low volume — under $3K/month, don't stress about it.

But once you cross $5K/month, interchange-plus saves real money. At $25K+, you're giving away thousands per year to Square or Stripe that could be in your pocket.

The biggest driver for Canadian businesses is Interac debit. No other country has a domestic debit network this cheap.

Use your actual credit and debit mix, channel, and average ticket to compare complete quotes.