Quick Answer: Helcim is the cheapest option for most Canadian businesses processing over $3,000/month. Below $3,000/month, the difference between processors is minimal β€” choose based on features.

Understanding Why Fees Differ

Payment processing fees in Canada consist of three layers:

  1. Interchange: Paid to the card-issuing bank. Set by Visa/Mastercard. Non-negotiable. Typical range: 0.5%–2.5%.
  2. Assessment fee: Paid to Visa/Mastercard network. Tiny (~0.08–0.13%). Non-negotiable.
  3. Processor markup: What your payment processor keeps. This is where costs vary dramatically between providers.

Square’s published Canadian rates are 2.5% for in-person credit, 2.8% + $0.30 for standard online payments, and 0.75% + $0.07 for in-person Interac debit. Calculate costs using the relevant channel and ticket size; these are not interchangeable rates. Source: Square Canada.

Interchange-plus processors (Helcim) charge you the actual interchange + a small fixed markup. You pay exactly what the card costs β€” no more.

Cheapest Processor by Monthly Volume

Assumptions: 70% in-person, 30% online, average ticket $65, 200 transactions/month, average interchange 1.60%

VolumeHelcim (IC+)Square (Flat)Stripe (Flat)MonerisWinner
$1,000/mo$24$26$30$50Helcim (barely)
$3,000/mo$63$78$87$98Helcim
$10,000/mo$200$260$290$270Helcim (saves $60–$90/mo)
$25,000/mo$475$650$725$637Helcim (saves $175–$250/mo)
$50,000/mo$895$1,300$1,450$1,248Helcim (saves $400–$555/mo)
$100,000/mo$1,680$2,600$2,900$2,445Helcim (saves $900–$1,220/mo)

When Flat-Rate IS Cheaper

Flat-rate pricing (Square, Stripe) can actually beat Helcim's interchange-plus in specific scenarios:

Hidden Costs That Affect Total Cost

The processing rate is just part of your total cost. Factor in:

How to Lower Your Processing Costs

1. Switch to Interchange-Plus Pricing

This is the single biggest lever. Most businesses that switch from flat-rate to Helcim's interchange-plus save $50–$500/month depending on volume.

2. Encourage Interac Debit Payments

Interac debit fees are tiny β€” often $0.08–$0.15 per transaction vs. 1.5–2.0% for credit cards. On a $100 purchase, that's $0.12 vs. $1.75.

If you can encourage customers to pay with debit, your effective rate drops significantly.

3. Eliminate Monthly Fees

Switch from Moneris ($25–$50/month) to Helcim ($0/month) and you save $300–$600/year before touching processing rates.

4. Reduce Chargebacks

Implement clear refund policies, use address verification, and require CVV for online orders. Each avoided chargeback saves $15–$25 plus the transaction amount.

5. Negotiate at Volume

Processors including Stripe and Moneris offer negotiated rates once you hit $50,000–$80,000/month in processing. It's worth the 20-minute phone call.

Example Savings: A Canadian retail store processing $30,000/month switching from Square (2.6%) to Helcim (avg ~1.78%) would save approximately $246/month β€” or $2,952/year. That's worth 5 minutes of research.

Cheapest Option Summary

  • Under $2,000/month: Square or Stripe (simplicity wins, cost difference minimal)
  • Helcim’s all-in credit cost depends on the underlying card fees, processing channel, ticket size, and volume tier. Its base Canadian markups are 0.40% + $0.08 in person and 0.50% + $0.25 online, in addition to underlying card costs. A fixed average rate or savings amount cannot be assumed for every merchant. Source: Helcim Canadian fee disclosure.
  • Over $100,000/month: Helcim or negotiate custom interchange+ with Moneris/Chase