The real problem with Canadian merchant statements
Your processor quoted you 1.75% or 2.3% — and that sounded reasonable. But what actually shows up on the statement is a different story. There's interchange, a markup, an assessment fee, a PCI fee, a monthly minimum, a batch fee, a gateway fee, maybe a terminal rental, and sometimes a few lines labeled things like "downgrade" or "authorization surcharge" that nobody explained at signup.
Divide the fees actually billed by card sales from the same period. Record processing separately from equipment, software and other charges so you can compare two offers covering the same services.
What's a normal rate vs what to question
Average sale, card mix and sales channel affect the effective rate. Compare like-for-like sales and ask about any line you cannot match to your agreement. Review the published Canadian rates and sources for Stripe, Square and Helcim.
The line items worth checking
- Confirm whether a monthly minimum on the contract resulted in a shortfall charge on this statement.
- Check the number of terminals on a rental invoice and whether their lease continues if you switch.
- Ask which transactions triggered a downgrade charge or an authorization fee. Count fees included in a bundled charge only once.
Interchange-plus, flat-rate and tiered pricing
Interchange-plus adds a processor markup to underlying card costs. A flat-rate plan can have different prices for credit, Interac debit and online payments. A tiered offer can have several prices for the same channel. Ask your provider to explain how your transactions fall into those categories.
See interchange-plus vs flat-rate explained and full fee comparison for more detail on each model.
When to consider switching
Compare the alternatives with the cost of keeping the same services. An estimate that depends on an unknown interchange rate, a missing subscription price or an unconfirmed contract payout needs a written quote.
See when to switch payment processors for a fuller checklist of what to review before making a move.
If you're considering moving some volume to Interac e-Transfer to avoid card fees on large invoices, use the Interac e-Transfer Suitability Checker first — there are real trade-offs around refunds and reconciliation that most processors don't mention.